Ukraine-Moldova-Transnistria: golden triangle of smuggling
Almost every month, law enforcement officers of Ukraine report about delaying of alcohol and cigarettes smuggling from Moldova. However, in Ukraine the quantity of smuggled goods does not become less–“Privoz” in Odessa, which is one of the oldest and largest existing markets in Europe, is crowded with contraband cigarettes. They sell it without checks and excise duties are questionable. Internet is full of proposals of Moldovan cigaretteswholesale. However, official data indicates that for more than two years Moldovacigarettesare not imported to Ukraine. However, traders are ready to sell illegal goodsby blocks, which prove the magnitude of the supply of smuggled goods. Moreover, contraband cigarettes are often produced in the Transnistria, registering a business in Moldova and Ukraine and ferrying, to the European Union as well. We were trying to understand where and how smuggled cigarettes come to Ukraine.
Smuggled cigarettes at “Privoz”
- Where can I buy Moldovan cigarettes? –I askedthe traders at the "Privoz".
- Now they are being chased, but ask around!
We go in rows. There used to sell cigarettes “from the floor", could even take a piece, although, according to a new Tax Code, all excisable goods should be sold only through the cash register. Now law enforcement officers often make raids atthe "Privoz", chase merchants of smuggled goods. But in some places you can still find old women, selling cigarettes directly "from hands".
However, for the smuggled goods at the "Privoz" are set the whole kiosks. We go to one of them:
- Can I buy cigarettes "Rich" (officially produced in Russia, but banned for import to Ukraine, according to the sanctions list, are often imported to the country from Transnistria, located in the orbit of Russian influence)?
- Yes, it is possible –replied the seller.
- Can I take a block? What’s the price?
- Of course you can!
On the shelves of tobacco shops there are many exotic cigarettes, which cannot be found in regular stores. Sellers are assured: you can buy a couple of blocks. Kiosks are not equipped with cash registers, the calculation is carried out for the cash, how they pay 5% -tax to local budgets is unknown.
In fact, trading Odessa was always "famous" for the flow of contraband goods from around the world. In modern times nothing has changed in this regard, since the Odessa region is a border, and the proximity to the unrecognized republic of Transnistria only contributes to the illegal movement of goods across the border.
The issue of sales of smuggled cigarettes is also easy to solve - at the "Privoz" you can sell and buy everything, as Odessa residentsjoke themselves. In late 2014 the Tax Code of Ukraine was changed - all excisable goods, so cigarettes as well,should be implemented through a cash register, and the tax on them –goes also to the local budgets. But at the "Privoz", despite often pressuresof law enforcement officers, cigarettes, as before, you can buy even "from hands". There are cigarettes, that in Ukraine the official manufacturers do not produce - for example, the Moldovan "Astra", supposedly English cigarettes "Business Club", the Greek "Asmoloff" and many others.
Cigarettes bought at "Privoz"
And due to SFS data, the cigarettes are imported to Ukraine illegally. They cost often cheap, in many there are no excise duties, indicating the illegal delivery of the goods. If there is excise duty, externally it differs from legal cigarettes. The further away from the famous market - the more surprised are eyes of the sellers at the request to sell unusual cigarettes. It should be noted that the Internet is full of proposals tobuy Moldovan cigarettes in Ukraine.
Official: Ukraine does not import cigarettes from Moldova
However, the official numbers are staggering: cigarettes from Moldova were not deliveredto Ukraine for more than two years. Thus, all the exotic cigarettes - Moldavian "Astra", "Rich", "Asmoloff" and others –get on the shelves illegally. We know that smuggling is an illegal movement of goods and property across the state border, with violation of the customs legislation. It causes damage to the state, measured in millions UAH, or hundreds of thousands USD. Profit of smugglers is enormous.
For example, the information only about July 2016 indicates that law enforcement officers of Odessa region seized, only in one case, more than 72 thousand packs of illegal cigarettes, worth a total of 1.354 million UAH. Smuggler was Ukrainian citizen. The brands are such as "Arctic", "Monomakh", "Mark", "Prima" and others. The employees of Odessa customs prevent also smuggling of excise stamps from Ukraine to Moldova.
So, in March of this year in Chernomorsk, Odessa region, was stopped the car, moving by ferry, which revealed 12.6 million excise stamps for tobacco products, produced in Russia. The driver turned out to be a Turkish citizen, who was carrying contraband to Moldova.
As explained the head of the press service of the Southern Regional Department of the State Border Service of Ukraine Andriy Beloborodchenko, the number of detentions of smuggled goods at the border in Odessa region is increasing: for example, in 2014 it was revealed 128 cases of illegal movement of tobacco products across the border, seized 2.159 million packs of cigarettes,last year - 75 cases of arrests, seized more than 4 million 280 thousand packs, in the first half of this year have already found 42 cases of trafficking of smuggled goods, seized more than 2 million packs. Analyzing this statistics, it becomes obvious that the smugglers, in the pursuit of profit,are trying to transportto Ukraine as much goods as possible.
However, according to the State Fiscal Service of Ukraine, the import of tobacco products from the Republic of Moldova to Ukraine was not carried out in 2015, as well as in 2014. Whereas in 2013 the total amount of tobacco, imported to Ukraine, was83 tons, for total cost 565,000 USD. Ukraine systematicallydelivers tobacco to Moldova: so 4215 tons, worth about 45 thousand US dollars was exported last year. It is obvious that the Moldavian cigarettes on the shelves of Ukrainian shops get illegally.
It should also be emphasized that the official data on exports of cigarettes from Moldova to Ukraine is radically different from the official response of Ukrainian fiscal services. Thus, according to the Bureau of Statistics of the Republic of Moldova, in 2014, cigarettes were imported to Ukraine, export was not carried out in 2015 and the current year.
Schemes of smugglers
As was explained by representatives of Odessa customs, which is headed by YuliaMarushevska, smuggling networks operate in a double direction. For example, cigarettes are transported in and from Ukraine to Moldova, a destination - European Union countries. In both cases, it plays a crucial role in price difference. For example, in average, pack of cigarettes in Moldova and Ukraine worth up to US $ 1, the EU - more than $ 5.
Smugglers often hide cigarettes in cars and vans - for example, unwind doors, instrument panels, also designed various devices under the bottom of the car. Cigarettes are imported to Ukraine, as well as out of the country to the European Union. Position of the management of Odessa customs is, on the one hand, to intensify the fight against contraband, including the illegal movement of tobacco products, on the other - to reduce the number of audits, initiated by the inspectors.
Corruption = smuggling
But law enforcement agencies of Ukraine and Moldova for various reasons cannot, and sometimes do not want to discourage contraband flows. Thus, the total length of the border between Moldova and Ukraine is 1,222 km, of which 450 - with Transnistria. According to the State Border Service of Ukraine, on the border with Moldova operate 54 checkpoints, 41 of them - automobile, 8 - rail, 3 - river, 2 - ferry.
All border crossing points from Moldova are equipped with special equipment, including X-ray scannersof different types. In addition, five specialized mobile scanners Rapiscan M4507, used throughout the frontier territory of Moldova and periodically moved to the so-called risk areas. Basically, they were received in 2008-2009 from the European Union. In addition, other government agencies have equipment,which is used including at the customs posts. Yet, when it comes to smuggling, these complicated devices are turning almost into a pile of useless metal, because illegal goods are sold on the shelves of cigarette shops.
According to insider information, smuggling in Odessa region from Moldova and Transnistria goes through two channels: the so-called "greenterritory" - through uncontrolled by customs officers and border guards parts of the border between two countries, and through the "window" that is, the corridor given to the smugglers at border crossing points. Often the cigarettes are manufactured in the unrecognized Transnistria that allows making enormous profits, evading taxes to the budget.
For example, according to the so-called TMR Ministry of Justice voiced data, in the unrecognized republic runs a tobacco factory "Ukr-Dniester Group", which is engaged in the production of tobacco products in the city of Tiraspol. According to unverified information, the production of tobacco is put into operation alsoin another Transnistrian town of Dubossary. You can find another "registered" company, which is allegedly engaged in manufacturing tobacco products, in the base of the TMR data.
In a letter, addressed to the "Ministry of Economy" of the region, we have appealed to the authorities of the unrecognized Transnistrian republic on the volume of cigarettes produced, imported or exported in the TMR, but the request was for more than two months unanswered. Thus, to verify production of Transnistria tobacco factories is almost impossible. Meanwhile, on the shelves of tobacco kiosks can be found cigarettes, produced in the region; according to local residents plant belongs to the famous TMR company"Sheriff".
But it is obvious that for a tiny unrecognized republic with less than half a million population,three tobacco factories, it is known from open sources of information, are unnecessary. Cigarettes with signs of differences of separatist republic have repeatedly been identified by police officers whenthey catch smugglers. They work also for foreign markets, delivering products, taking into account the status of the "republic", illegally.
The above-mentioned company "Ukr-Dniester Group", which operates in Transnistria, under the same name in 2012, was registered in Ukraine. Legal address: Odessa, Devolanovsky descent, 11. According to the Classification of Economic Activities, Ltd. is engaged in manufacture of tobacco products and wholesale trade of tobacco products. According to the official data, the owner of the company is a businessman from Odessa Vladimir Rozengolts.
We have asked the company, but a response has not been received yet. The law enforcement and intelligence agencies also have no claims to the enterprising Ukrainian, who allegedly sells products, produced in Transnistria, in Ukraine and possibly Moldova, bringing it by smuggling.
Black Hole TMR: loss of tens of millions, no one behind bars
Indeed, the very existence of the self-proclaimed "republic" outside the norms of international law, contributes to the implementation of the criminal schemes, which affect not only the neighboring countries, but also countries throughout the European Union.
In Moldova, for example, operate two government decisions - from September 2001 and August 2005, according to which Transnistrian companies are exempt from payments for imports of cigarettes and for environmental pollution. Entrepreneurs from Transnistria may qualify for benefits under the condition that enrolled in the State Register of enterprises and organizations of the State Register of the Republic of Moldova, as well as if you have received a license for the import and processing of tobacco, claiming its cargo to the competent authorities of customs. Thus, the "republican" companies actuallyare legalized. As a result of these fraudulent transactions,EU losses are estimated at tens of millions of euros, all go to the pockets of international criminals.
So, in 2014, were found a few companies in the unrecognized Transnistrian republic, importing cigarettes of Italian factories. The export transactions were reported in the European customs system and concluded fictitiously on the Moldovan-Romanian and Romanian-Ukrainian customs. Transnistrian companies, which took part in these schemes, - SRL "Alcazar", "Sarmat-Plus" SRL and others. To implement the criminal schemes were forged official documents of government agencies from Romania, Moldova and Ukraine.
Then the offense was identified by Moldova Service of Information and Security, together with the European Office for the fight against customs fraud OLAF and EUBAM. According to the press release of the Prosecutor General of Moldova,was initiated a criminal case under article 248. Later, from 2013 to 2016, prosecutors filed five criminal cases on money laundering and the movement of contraband goods, committed by SRL "Alcazar", "Sarmat-Plus" - companies from the Transnistrian region of Moldova.
The investigation found out that company SRL "Alcazar", haven’t been declaring the items when moving them across the border. State budget damage is estimated at about 8.4 million lei, or more than 430 thousand US dollars. The company "Sarmat-Plus" SRL has caused damage in a much larger amount - 253 million lei, that is almost $ 13 million USD.
However, until now the court is considered only one criminal case. According to the prosecutor Andrei Pascar, although the judge convicted the accused to a prison term for smuggling in a large scale, hehas not spent a single day in prison, came under conditional release. In other cases, the Prosecutor General of the Republic, together with the investigating teams of several EU countries continues to lead the investigation, the trial is still far.
In addition, Italy launched an investigation in two criminal cases against Italian companies-exporters. Previously, these illegal schemes were uncovered in Slovakia. Then it was the company «Yesmoke» from Italy, which passed the cigarettes through a fictitious destination in Spain and the customs warehouse in the Italian Torino. The purpose of these schemes was the evasion of excise duty. The company was registered on the deceased people. In the end, the goods were transferred to another company. Excise did not return, and the cigarettes illegally withdrawn from customs warehouses. Later, these cigarettes were found in Hungary and other EU countries.
The Slovak authorities have managed to prevent the fraudulent scheme involving Transnistrian companies «Sarmat Plus» and «Invest Capital Group». Cigarettes were to leave the EU territory without excise stamps, respectively, without paying for them. A few months after the official export of cigarettes the partyof «Yesmoke» was discovered in Eastern Slovakia. On suspicion of a crime were detained two Ukrainians.
Representatives of EUBAM commented on this issue, noting that the mission is working with Ukrainian and Moldovan partners on several levels: "The mission supports the tightening of legislation, restricting the smugglers, the development of strategies to combat trafficking in both countries and works quickly to our Ukrainian and Moldovan partners can identify, detect and prevent contraband goods. This includes support for closer cross-border exchange of information and operations, and support for more use of risk analysis. The mission also helped to establish contacts between two countries and international law enforcement agencies."
This situation has led to the fact that many times announced by EUBAM mission idea to create a joint Ukrainian-Moldovan customs checkpoints to prevent, in the first place, the illegal movement of goods, including the EU, will finally be implemented into practice in 2017. Perhaps, then will disappear contraband cigarettes and the budgets of both states will no longer bear the huge loss.
This investigation is accomplished within „Shining a Light on Corruption in Moldova” Project, carried out by the Center for Investigative Journalism and Freedom House, with the financial support of the Norwegian Foreign Ministry.
Investigations in the same category:
The war between Aliyev and Moser: How the Giurgiulesti International Free Port became EBRD property
● EBRD bought from the Austrian company Febania Gmbh, the Cypriot company ThoMo Invest LTD, which owned the Danube group of companies and, implicitly, the Giurgiulesti International Free Port ● Febania Gmbh Company was opened by the former manager of Danube Logistics SRL, Thomas Moser, on the eve of the unfavorable decision of the first instance court of Moldova in its dispute with Bemol ● Ahead of this deal, EBRD owned 65% of Danube Logistics Holding BV's revenues One of the most important strategic objectives of the Republic of Moldova - Giurgiulesti International Free Port - has become the subject of
How separatists in breakaway regions mine cryptocurrencies for terrorist financing and money laundering
● Characters from the Kremlin's entourage revolve around the cryptocurrency business in the pro-Russian separatist republics of Moldova and Ukraine. ● The mining activity takes place with cheap or free raw material guaranteed by Moscow. ● Legislation in this area is still in a grey zone, and Bitcoin has exceeded the level of 25,000 US dollars per unit. Andriy, 38, lives in a modest apartment in the eastern Ukrainian region of Donetsk. Unemployed, he decided to make some money by installing a "cryptocurrency farm" in his bedroom. He is already used to the noise of coolers, and the gain is guaranteed. "For a
SCHEMES // Protective equipment, made in Moldova, exported to Poland, as COVID-19 crisis is in full swing
In full swing of a pandemic crisis, when Moldovan hospitals are facing a lack of coronavirus protective equipment and Moldovan authorities spend millions of public money on their import, an economic agent from Balti is exporting protective equipment to Poland. The equipment was exported by two air flights, operated by Ryanair, on April 11 and 14, respectively. This happened amid the ban on the export of protective equipment, obviously, with the help of the authorities, who do not assume responsibility and say they have banned the export of gloves and masks, but not of protective equipment. The company that exported
● The main beneficiary of the cryptocurrency business in the breakaway region of Transnistria is the Sheriff holding and a former employee of the Interior Ministry of the Russian Federation. ● The equipment was purchased through a bank involved in the theft of the billion. ● The actors and companies involved have businesses in the energy sector, telecommunication, internet in Crimea and in the Western countries in Europe. Tehnopark company is located in the Business Center "Rossia", one of the most modern buildings in Tiraspol, the main city of the breakaway region of Transnistria, in contrast to the grey of Soviet architecture. This is a
European funded roads rehabilitated with significant delays
Four out of 13 companies, that have been shortlisted in international tenders over the last five years in order to rehabilitate the national roads of the Republic of Moldova, have been sanctioned for delays in the execution of the works. All fined companies are international and the amount of fines exceeds EUR 3.8 million. The four companies that were sanctioned for delays in the execution of the works were contracted during 2011-2014 for repairing several areas on national the routes Chisinau - Soroca, Chisinau - Comrat - Giurgiulesti, Chisinau - Ungheni - Sculeni and for the construction of Ungheni bypass
Bypass road, “bypassed” by the Authorities
Announced with great pomp in early 2012, Chisinau's bypass road remained just an unfulfilled promise. Five years after the announcement of the project, the authorities did not even develop a feasibility study to determine the need for the ring road and its route. In the absence of the “plan”, however, a construction company was contracted, which conducted only 3% of the works in two years on a bypass road segment that was to be ready in January 2018. The whole Bypass road would cost about EUR 200 million, money the authorities do not know where to take from. The first
Till the first earthquake happens
It's usually said about houses and building, constructed in the Republic of Moldova after 1991, they will resist before the first earthquake will happen. This is an emotional evaluation of things. And two earthquakes with a moderate magnitude that happened in September and December of 2016 proved it. What's the actual situation in the construction sphere? And, is there a possibility for a total damage to happen to a person and his property, because of builders or officials’ fault? Features in Moldavian constructions “When I was a student, my professors used to tell me: “There is an unique environment in
How several presidential candidates pocketed electoral money
The campaign for 2016 presidential elections with a budget worth almost 60 million lei has been one of the most expensive in Moldova so far. The money collected from thousands of sponsors: students, pensioners or unemployed, prosperous businessmen reached the accounts of some companies that manage TV channels. The main beneficiary of the electoral campaign held this autumn fall is the first deputy-chairman of the Democratic Party, owner of 4 TV channels. Most of the contenders aired election ads on these TV channels. About 40 per cent of electoral funds of the 12 candidates were paid to the accounts
The grain market in Moldova, under the Russian monopoly
The wheat harvest this year was plenteous, with an average quantity of 3.4 tons per hectare. Nevertheless, the small producers will not benefit of this situation, because they are compelled to sell their grains to a derisory price. The only beneficiary is Trans-Oil, a holding consisting in a series of off-shores registered in Switzerland and Cyprus and joint-stock companies form Ukraine, Moldova and Romania. The company is controlled by the Russian citizen Vazha Dzashi, who was born in Georgia (USSR), holds an American passport and hi is member of the Council of Administration of the Moldovan Businessman Association. Trans-Oil, a
New Airline Fly One and Private Interests of the Civil Aviation Authority Director, Confirmed by ISS
Mircea Maleca, Director of the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA), is allegedly the real business partner of the family of Ministry of Justice Vladimir Cebotari in the new airline company Fly One. The official is hiding behind his former father- in-law from Leova. This is confirmed by a letter signed by Mihai Balan, Director of the Information and Security Service (ISS), that recently came into possession of portal Anticoruptie.md. Although its authenticity is not confirmed, ISS heads claim in an official response that the CAA managers abuse power by promoting private interests in civil aviation, which would be contrary to
Energy (in)dependence of Ukraine and Moldova: After association with the EU
The desire to join the European Union, voiced by Ukraine and Moldova, set the agenda of the authorities, including the issue of the system of purchase and supply of natural gas. Nevertheless, the assessment of the situation to date, carried out by a group of journalists from Moldova and Ukraine, shows that the market of gas in both countries still has some problems, and carries the risk of corruption. Embezzlement of public funds, key intermediary firms of dubious reputation, monopoly - these are the main features of the gas market in the two post-Soviet countries. "Moldova to Russia’s pocket". How it
New Airline in the Pocket of the Minister of Justice
A new airline will operate in Moldova as of May 2016 and will transport passengers to several European cities. The company was registered last autumn and has as founders Maria Cebotari, wife of the current Minister of Justice, Vladimir Cebotari, while his sister, Mariana Tabuica, would be the new executive director. The Minister confirmed that his family started a new business and it's just a way to earn a living. "Just like any citizen of this country, I cope with problems", says the official who gets a monthly income from ministerial activity of about 16,000 lei. Initially, Fly One promises flights
False Flags of Moldova: Azerbaijan-Netherland’s Track
The story of Giurgiulești port, „the incubator” of Moldavian flag for ships business, begins with an extremely onerous business involving the communists led by former president Vladimir Voronin, Azerbaijan businessmen and companies, Swiss credit companies, other companies registered in the Netherlands, as well as a BERD former employee that later became one of the business heads. One of the constant players that are to be described later on is the business man, Thomas Mosser. The story of the Romanian port of Giurgiulești began in 1993 when Andrei Sangheli, Moldavian former prime minister intended to build a port right in the
"Platonic" Ukrainians’ businesses in Chisinau
Oleksandr Pinchuk, a Ukrainian national and a former head of the National Bureau of Motor Vehicle Insurers of the Republic of Moldova, has been on the wanted list of the Moldovan authorities for almost a year by now. He became a key person of interest for the National Anticorruption Centre and the Anticorruption Prosecution Office when the Bureau suffered 30 million leu damages. However, Pinchuk, who is also a successful lawyer from Ukraine, goes to work every day, meets his partners and participates in public life of the neighboring state without any problems. We have found him and even talked
Audit with interests? Who owns the companies selected by the Ministry of Finance to carry out financial controls at state enterprises?
The government has recently approved a list of 37 audit companies, filled by the Ministry of Finance, that will audit the financial statements of state enterprises or companies in which the state share exceeds 50 percent of the social capital. One of the companies approved to make checks in 2015 is that of Ion Prisacaru, head of the State Tax Inspectorate (STI) and other companies related to former employees of Finance Ministry. The National Anti-Corruption Center (CNA) conducted a survey on the corruptibility of the draft decision of the Government in March and warned about situations of conflicts of
Off-SHOR Airport via Russia (II)
To ensure incomes estimated at over one billion Euros to the company „Avia Invest”, managed by the current mayor of Orhei Ilan Shor, the main suspect in the case on the theft of billion from the financial-banking system of the Republic of Moldova, the Government does not want to annul an airport fee which the National Anticorruption Center (CNA) reported that it was perceived illegally. From the central rostrum of Parliament, the CNA director suggests that money stolen from BEM is laundered at the Airport, but the officials from the Center who investigate the case wait for answers from Russia.
Off-SHOR Airport via Russia
Chisinau International Airport (AIC) lease is one of the most controversial "businesses" concluded by the Government of the Republic of Moldova in recent years. Although 5 European companies with experience in airport activity were invited to participate in the contest, the competition commission chose an anonymous company, founded by an airport in Russia and a Russian factory of locomotives production, which ceded the "business" to an off-shore. Today, investments in Airport modernization are made mostly based on money from the activity of AIC transferred to the accounts of companies close to Ilan Shor. „Business” AIC - An opaque contest, won by
The confidential report of the Commission of Minister Cebotari and Airport leasing
President of the Commission on assessing the Chisinau International Airport leasing agreement, Minister of Justice Vladimir Cebotari admitted that "Avia Invest" has not fulfilled some of the provisions stipulated by the agreement, but he argues that there are no grounds for terminating the agreement. Termination was recommended by the National Anti-Corruption Center, after they had identified some irregularities about set investments and after certain revenues of the airport would have arrived at the football club of mayor in Orhei, Ilan Sor. Ex-Prime Minister Valeriu Strelet claims that the first part of the Report shows grounds for termination and the
Companies of Iurcu’s friends continue to win contracts with Moldtelecom
Companies affiliated to Vitalie Iurcu, currently Deputy Minister of Economy and ex-director of Moldtelecom, continue to be key procurement partners of the joint venture owned by the state, even after he left the company. Recently, just through one invoice, to the firm’s accounts established by Iurcu’s friends, were transferred 700,000 lei. Previously, we demonstrated how several companies belonging to friends or business partnersof VitalieIurcu, then director of Moldelecom, obtained multi-million contracts with this joint stock company owned by the state. The information is now confirmed by recent acts, which came into our possession, demonstrating that Moldtelecom continues to buy from
The stories from www.anticoruptie.md may be used in the limit of up to 1,000 characters. Web pages must indicate the source and link directly to the article. Print media, Radio and TV stations must indicate the source. Publishing full version of stories is allowed based on a prior agreement with the Center for Investigative Journalism. Articles published on www.anticoruptie.md are protected by the Law on copyright and related rights of Republic of Moldova.